This post is long overdue. Before leaving for Wales, I was constantly asked about the division of UK politics. I generally equated it to the US system – drawing parallels between US states and the UK regions of Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. After nearly three months at the National Assembly, I can assure everyone that the system produced by devolution is no where near as efficient as that analogy suggests. (Devolution – process in which the UK government, centred in Westminster London, grants power to regional governments in Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland) Each region is at a vastly different stage of the process, just to make things a little more confusing.
Unlike US states (or even local governments), the Welsh government does not have the power to levy taxes (Scotland has extremely limited powers on this front) – which means the devolved governments receive all of their funding from the central UK government. The exact amount is determined through the convoluted Barnett Formula which is supposed to grant each region their fair share according to its devolved powers. For example, if the UK government increases funding for the armed forces, regional funding doesn’t change (the military benefits all of the UK equally). If it invests a million pounds into a new education scheme (devolved issue), Welsh funding increases by a percentage of that million (I forget the exact percentage – but it accounts for population differences among other issues). As the devolved regions tend to get a better deal in the end, there's a bit of tension here.
And then we reach the problem of deciding who legislates what. On fully devolved matters, the issue is simple enough – but very few issues are fully devolved once you really start considering it. For example, the environment is a devolved issue – but the Assembly can’t legislatively do anything other than “encourage” energy efficiency (efficiency regulations and prohibitions are not devolved). That is only one of very many examples. To fix this, the Assembly can submit an LCO (Legislative Competence Order) requesting the power to legislate a specific matter. This comes with a multitude of problems. The first is agreeing to submit an LCO in the first place. Deciding how far to go when asking for powers (do you take the opportunity to ask for everything you want or focus on what’s immediately necessary – then you have to account for party politics) is another huge issue. Not to mention the fact that people are generally annoyed that the Assembly has to go beg for powers from London – the subservient instead of equal thing again.
Recently, David’s proposal for an LCO was pulled for consideration. Though Welsh language is a devolved matter, the Assembly does not have power to create an independent regulator to ensure that language equality laws are adhered to across the nation (or region, if you like) – such as in Ireland or Canada (there is a Welsh Language Board, but most people seem to agree that a regulator position would be much more effective). After careful preparation for debate, the LCO was shot down because Labour (currently in Government through coalition with Plaid Cyrmu – meaning that together they have a majority) did not think the proposal went far enough (they also want power to make Welsh an official language – oddly enough another power that apparently doesn’t fall under the Welsh language field). So despite the fact that they agree a regulator would be a good thing, the LCO didn’t pass.
This is not to say that the Assembly is hamstrung at every path to be effective. The AMs generally have a good sense of what is devolved and are effective in legislating within those parameters. The agricultural and rural policies are generally recognized as highly effective, and there has been a ton of legislation concerning education, transportation, and health to name a few. I’m just trying to give a sense of the frustration that often plagues the process.
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Can getting lost be a hobby?
Two weeks ago, Chris (freshman roommate, current Rotary Scholar in Sweden) popped over to the UK for a weekend visit. Ridiculous adventures ensued. I took Friday off to meet up with her in Oxford and we spent most of the day walking around the city catching up. In the midst of our gossip, I did get a chance to see the main sites and even managed a quick tour of The Kilns (C.S. Lewis's house) as Chris is friends with the woman who is currently living there/worked to restore it.
On Sunday, we headed out for Tintern Abbey after carefully writing down the various trains and buses we would need to get there in one piece. Our original plan had been a trip to Hay-on-Wye but we were discouraged after being told by several people the only realistic way to get there is by driving (we were smart enough to resist their recommendations to rent a vehicle and drive ourselves). The first leg of the journey was highly successful – we caught a train to the middle of nothing and nowhere (not a pub in site) and successfully walked to the bus stop (also in the middle of nothing and nowhere) only to find a message indicating “No Forthcoming Departures” instead of the normal list of buses. We were five minutes early according to the posted bus schedule so we decided to wait it out. Forty-five minutes later, it was time to try Plan B so we headed back to the train station only to discover there was nowhere to buy tickets – so taking the train back was not an option. At this point in the journey, a normal person might have waited for the next train and bought a ticket from the conductor. But Chris noticed a tiny footpath that cut behind a cow field, so we decided to take that in the hopes it lead to a town with warm food and a bus back to Cardiff. About forty minutes later our footpath turned into old railway tracks but there was still no sign of life. We pressed on. Eventually the path dumped us into the back of a residential neighborhood (still no pub, but at least other people were out) and we started looking for the town centre. A little over an hour later (after a sketchy experience ducking into a men-only athletic facility for a restroom), we found a few shops. Since it was Sunday, everything was closed but we were encouraged nonetheless – after finding a map of the town we discovered we were located in Caldicot and there was a castle nearby (not surprising as castles are rather ubiquitous in Wales). It was also pretty obvious that we had managed to walk in circles before finally hitting civilization – apparently roaming around cow and sheep fields wasn’t as productive as originally thought. We got pub recommendations and made our way over for a wonderful meal of steak and ale pie before heading out to the castle and a quick round of exploring the surrounding grounds. The trip back was a little touch-and-go with the buses, but we eventually arrived back in Cardiff.
In other news, I promise a post about the Assembly/what I’m doing/etc. soon. November has flown by, and I’ve been crazy busy.
Pictures from various Welsh castles and Cardiff.
On Sunday, we headed out for Tintern Abbey after carefully writing down the various trains and buses we would need to get there in one piece. Our original plan had been a trip to Hay-on-Wye but we were discouraged after being told by several people the only realistic way to get there is by driving (we were smart enough to resist their recommendations to rent a vehicle and drive ourselves). The first leg of the journey was highly successful – we caught a train to the middle of nothing and nowhere (not a pub in site) and successfully walked to the bus stop (also in the middle of nothing and nowhere) only to find a message indicating “No Forthcoming Departures” instead of the normal list of buses. We were five minutes early according to the posted bus schedule so we decided to wait it out. Forty-five minutes later, it was time to try Plan B so we headed back to the train station only to discover there was nowhere to buy tickets – so taking the train back was not an option. At this point in the journey, a normal person might have waited for the next train and bought a ticket from the conductor. But Chris noticed a tiny footpath that cut behind a cow field, so we decided to take that in the hopes it lead to a town with warm food and a bus back to Cardiff. About forty minutes later our footpath turned into old railway tracks but there was still no sign of life. We pressed on. Eventually the path dumped us into the back of a residential neighborhood (still no pub, but at least other people were out) and we started looking for the town centre. A little over an hour later (after a sketchy experience ducking into a men-only athletic facility for a restroom), we found a few shops. Since it was Sunday, everything was closed but we were encouraged nonetheless – after finding a map of the town we discovered we were located in Caldicot and there was a castle nearby (not surprising as castles are rather ubiquitous in Wales). It was also pretty obvious that we had managed to walk in circles before finally hitting civilization – apparently roaming around cow and sheep fields wasn’t as productive as originally thought. We got pub recommendations and made our way over for a wonderful meal of steak and ale pie before heading out to the castle and a quick round of exploring the surrounding grounds. The trip back was a little touch-and-go with the buses, but we eventually arrived back in Cardiff.
In other news, I promise a post about the Assembly/what I’m doing/etc. soon. November has flown by, and I’ve been crazy busy.
Pictures from various Welsh castles and Cardiff.
Saturday, November 15, 2008
Belfast and Beyond
Two weeks ago was half-term for the Assembly – essentially a week without plenary or committee meetings. Contrary to popular belief, this does not mean work completely stops and everyone goes on vacation (quite a sore point with many support staffers) – but it does mean that I got a few days vacation. Off to Belfast in Northern Ireland with Ariel, a fellow W&M alum who is currently on a Fulbright to Andorra, followed by a quick trip to London on my way back to Cardiff (oh, cheap plane tickets – how I will miss you in the US).
As normal, I was rather obsessive about every second of the transport and hostel planning – house to airport, airport to hostel, London to Cardiff, hostel has decent security, lockers, etc. But I rarely plan anything for the time I’ll actually be there. It has the effect of making me feel very organized at the onset, and then I get there and realize I have absolutely no idea what to do with myself. Luckily, the people I travel with tend to consider these things more carefully. Ariel, being no exception, suggested a day trip to Giant’s Causeway – a beach on the northern coast with oddly symmetric rock formations and absolutely gorgeous views (I realize it sounds boring – it’s not). It definitely lived up to expectations – the vividness of the colors in Ireland’s landscape is a bit surreal. Here are some of my pictures. The trip was a perfect break. While I’m not normally a fan of over-planned herd-like tourist excursions, our guide was pretty ridiculous which made the entire experience worthwhile (at one point gleefully announcing that he could speak American – immediately launching into a butchered rendition of Clinton’s adultery apology from ten years ago - it was simultaneously hilarious and horrifying). Mostly it was nice not to plan the outing through the public bus system, memorizing a sheaf of numbers and schedules to get from point to point (as crossing the street is quite a dangerous task for me with the opposite traffic flow, I wouldn’t dare to drive myself).
We spent Friday exploring the city itself. First stop, the Linen Hall Library (I’ve recently developed a bit of an obsession with libraries) – which is absolutely beautiful: tall ceilings, floor-to-ceiling bookshelves, old leather chairs, large windows, and an amazing collection of books. There are signs posted announcing that books published after the 1859 are now available for check-out – can you imagine taking something that valuable home from your local library? And books older that that just chilling on the shelves for anyone to flip through if they so desire. On some level, I feel that this is wrong, but completely amazing at the same time. Then I realized I was obsessing a bit.
Next stop, the botanical gardens, followed by a walking tour of the city itself. Again, we were graced with a wonderful tour guide who led us through the streets, pointing out the modern buildings mixed with incredibly old ones. It’s something you can’t help but notice as a pedestrian, but the reason never crossed my mind until it was blatantly pointed out. Due to the violence during The Troubles, many buildings were bombed and modern ones have now been re-built in their place. Right.
That same uneasy feeling came back later in the day when we decided to check out the city Halloween festivities – located near the docks, we made our way by following the general flow of the crowd and ended up in a huge open field crammed with people. Unfortunately, abundant Halloween costumes combined with the feeling of being herded like cattle to wait for some unknown event (we weren’t exactly sure what happened at the Halloween festivities) was a bit unsettling – especially since the police were everywhere (I realize the police should make you feel better, but I wasn’t getting that sense from this crowd. Yes, I may be paranoid). So we left. We wrapped up the evening at a cute little restaurant for tea with amazing shortcake and a bit of costume watching. Located on a corner, two walls were floor to ceiling windows – next to an ATM, across the street from a theatre, and apparently between two major Halloween clubs – in other words, the perfect place to people watch while laughing at the various costume choices and general drunken craziness. Those running the shop apparently enjoyed our running commentary as they wouldn’t let us pay for anything before we left.
We wrapped up the trip the following afternoon, and I moved on to London for a short bit of sightseeing. A wonderful break from Cardiff, though I was definitely glad to get back Sunday night.
As normal, I was rather obsessive about every second of the transport and hostel planning – house to airport, airport to hostel, London to Cardiff, hostel has decent security, lockers, etc. But I rarely plan anything for the time I’ll actually be there. It has the effect of making me feel very organized at the onset, and then I get there and realize I have absolutely no idea what to do with myself. Luckily, the people I travel with tend to consider these things more carefully. Ariel, being no exception, suggested a day trip to Giant’s Causeway – a beach on the northern coast with oddly symmetric rock formations and absolutely gorgeous views (I realize it sounds boring – it’s not). It definitely lived up to expectations – the vividness of the colors in Ireland’s landscape is a bit surreal. Here are some of my pictures. The trip was a perfect break. While I’m not normally a fan of over-planned herd-like tourist excursions, our guide was pretty ridiculous which made the entire experience worthwhile (at one point gleefully announcing that he could speak American – immediately launching into a butchered rendition of Clinton’s adultery apology from ten years ago - it was simultaneously hilarious and horrifying). Mostly it was nice not to plan the outing through the public bus system, memorizing a sheaf of numbers and schedules to get from point to point (as crossing the street is quite a dangerous task for me with the opposite traffic flow, I wouldn’t dare to drive myself).
We spent Friday exploring the city itself. First stop, the Linen Hall Library (I’ve recently developed a bit of an obsession with libraries) – which is absolutely beautiful: tall ceilings, floor-to-ceiling bookshelves, old leather chairs, large windows, and an amazing collection of books. There are signs posted announcing that books published after the 1859 are now available for check-out – can you imagine taking something that valuable home from your local library? And books older that that just chilling on the shelves for anyone to flip through if they so desire. On some level, I feel that this is wrong, but completely amazing at the same time. Then I realized I was obsessing a bit.
Next stop, the botanical gardens, followed by a walking tour of the city itself. Again, we were graced with a wonderful tour guide who led us through the streets, pointing out the modern buildings mixed with incredibly old ones. It’s something you can’t help but notice as a pedestrian, but the reason never crossed my mind until it was blatantly pointed out. Due to the violence during The Troubles, many buildings were bombed and modern ones have now been re-built in their place. Right.
That same uneasy feeling came back later in the day when we decided to check out the city Halloween festivities – located near the docks, we made our way by following the general flow of the crowd and ended up in a huge open field crammed with people. Unfortunately, abundant Halloween costumes combined with the feeling of being herded like cattle to wait for some unknown event (we weren’t exactly sure what happened at the Halloween festivities) was a bit unsettling – especially since the police were everywhere (I realize the police should make you feel better, but I wasn’t getting that sense from this crowd. Yes, I may be paranoid). So we left. We wrapped up the evening at a cute little restaurant for tea with amazing shortcake and a bit of costume watching. Located on a corner, two walls were floor to ceiling windows – next to an ATM, across the street from a theatre, and apparently between two major Halloween clubs – in other words, the perfect place to people watch while laughing at the various costume choices and general drunken craziness. Those running the shop apparently enjoyed our running commentary as they wouldn’t let us pay for anything before we left.
We wrapped up the trip the following afternoon, and I moved on to London for a short bit of sightseeing. A wonderful break from Cardiff, though I was definitely glad to get back Sunday night.
Wednesday, November 5, 2008
Election Night/Morning
It’s 4:30am on November 5th, and I just woke up to watch the election results come in. At 11:30pm Eastern Time, the results are already here. Obama won!
Obviously, I’m ecstatic. Watching this election from the UK has been a very interesting experience – being here has given me a new appreciation of American politics. At first it all seemed quite removed from the UK – but I quickly realized that was far from the truth. There have been documentaries about the US almost every night, and yesterday the BBC gave essentially 24/7 coverage to the election – talking to voters, speculating on the outcome, and essentially covering all the bases I’m sure CNN was. My co-workers debated staying up all night to watch the results come in versus getting up early when more information would be available. I opted for the up at 4am option, convinced no real information would be available before then (this is, after all, 11pm in Virginia). I turned the TV on just in time for McCain’s concession speech – it was quite surreal and I spent a decent part of it debating whether I was dreaming or not. A strong cup of tea is helping to convince me I am, in fact, awake. If this seems normal to you, take a moment to think about the (lack of) coverage and national attention UK elections get in the States. So watching that level of coverage for the US election here was a little strange.
It’s also been kind of humbling – though that’s not quite the right word, I can’t think of one to capture the sentiment. US policies obviously have enormous international consequences. At times, it’s frustrating to think of how insignificant an individual vote feels – elections are rarely decided with small voter margins and this one is no exception. But take a moment to imagine the frustration of not having any part in a process which still has a huge effect on your life. Americans often get upset when foreign leaders or media sources weigh in with opinions in upcoming elections, but given the effect a single election has globally it seems almost irresponsible not to at least voice your opinion. I don’t really know what I’m trying to say here. In my defense, it’s early and the caffeine has yet to set in.
The last few weeks I’ve been bombarded with people questioning me about the absolute worst of US stereotypes. Individuals who confidently knew that, despite the hype, America would never elect a black man to office; firm and often caustic believers in the infamous Bradley Effect who looked on my hope of an Obama victory as rather naïve. While I recognize that race has played a role in this election, for both sides, it’s quite frustrating to confront these stereotypes on a daily basis. I may not agree with McCain supporters, but I certainly don’t think they’re racists (yes, a small percentage are – but certainly nothing close to a majority). In Belfast, I was asked by almost everyone I met two questions. Who I voted for, and if I thought Obama would be assassinated. The second one never failed to reduce me to a stuttering mess.
“No! I don’t think so.” (Sarcastic smirk from the questioner – practically screams “You naïve American.”) “I certainly hope not. I don’t know for sure I guess. How do you answer that? I can’t predict the future, but I really don’t think so. I certainly hope not.” (Slight concern and apologies at my blatant discomfort).
Obviously this question is highly influenced by the political violence which has only recently calmed (but certainly not disappeared) in Northern Ireland – however it’s also a reflection of those Bradley Effect believers who feel that Americans are generally intolerant. It’s hard to convey that, while there are certainly intolerant individuals whose actions you can’t predict, the majority of Americans truly aren’t racist. While I obviously support Obama for his policies, I don’t think I truly appreciated the significance of a black US President until these last few weeks (growing up in an age of political correctness, I kind of assumed there would be a black US President, just as I assume there will soon be a woman president – as I felt it was obvious, I never really considered the implications of it actually happening).
I don’t mean to suggest that everyone here feels Americans are intolerant. A majority are thoroughly enthralled with the entire process –helping to ensure future 24/7 coverage of elections with their car accident-like fascination with the process. I fend off just as many questions about the Electoral College, Congressional elections, and historical state voting patterns as anything else – though it’s hard to convey the significance of North Carolina as a battleground state without reinforcing those earlier stereotypes.
Obviously, I’m ecstatic. Watching this election from the UK has been a very interesting experience – being here has given me a new appreciation of American politics. At first it all seemed quite removed from the UK – but I quickly realized that was far from the truth. There have been documentaries about the US almost every night, and yesterday the BBC gave essentially 24/7 coverage to the election – talking to voters, speculating on the outcome, and essentially covering all the bases I’m sure CNN was. My co-workers debated staying up all night to watch the results come in versus getting up early when more information would be available. I opted for the up at 4am option, convinced no real information would be available before then (this is, after all, 11pm in Virginia). I turned the TV on just in time for McCain’s concession speech – it was quite surreal and I spent a decent part of it debating whether I was dreaming or not. A strong cup of tea is helping to convince me I am, in fact, awake. If this seems normal to you, take a moment to think about the (lack of) coverage and national attention UK elections get in the States. So watching that level of coverage for the US election here was a little strange.
It’s also been kind of humbling – though that’s not quite the right word, I can’t think of one to capture the sentiment. US policies obviously have enormous international consequences. At times, it’s frustrating to think of how insignificant an individual vote feels – elections are rarely decided with small voter margins and this one is no exception. But take a moment to imagine the frustration of not having any part in a process which still has a huge effect on your life. Americans often get upset when foreign leaders or media sources weigh in with opinions in upcoming elections, but given the effect a single election has globally it seems almost irresponsible not to at least voice your opinion. I don’t really know what I’m trying to say here. In my defense, it’s early and the caffeine has yet to set in.
The last few weeks I’ve been bombarded with people questioning me about the absolute worst of US stereotypes. Individuals who confidently knew that, despite the hype, America would never elect a black man to office; firm and often caustic believers in the infamous Bradley Effect who looked on my hope of an Obama victory as rather naïve. While I recognize that race has played a role in this election, for both sides, it’s quite frustrating to confront these stereotypes on a daily basis. I may not agree with McCain supporters, but I certainly don’t think they’re racists (yes, a small percentage are – but certainly nothing close to a majority). In Belfast, I was asked by almost everyone I met two questions. Who I voted for, and if I thought Obama would be assassinated. The second one never failed to reduce me to a stuttering mess.
“No! I don’t think so.” (Sarcastic smirk from the questioner – practically screams “You naïve American.”) “I certainly hope not. I don’t know for sure I guess. How do you answer that? I can’t predict the future, but I really don’t think so. I certainly hope not.” (Slight concern and apologies at my blatant discomfort).
Obviously this question is highly influenced by the political violence which has only recently calmed (but certainly not disappeared) in Northern Ireland – however it’s also a reflection of those Bradley Effect believers who feel that Americans are generally intolerant. It’s hard to convey that, while there are certainly intolerant individuals whose actions you can’t predict, the majority of Americans truly aren’t racist. While I obviously support Obama for his policies, I don’t think I truly appreciated the significance of a black US President until these last few weeks (growing up in an age of political correctness, I kind of assumed there would be a black US President, just as I assume there will soon be a woman president – as I felt it was obvious, I never really considered the implications of it actually happening).
I don’t mean to suggest that everyone here feels Americans are intolerant. A majority are thoroughly enthralled with the entire process –helping to ensure future 24/7 coverage of elections with their car accident-like fascination with the process. I fend off just as many questions about the Electoral College, Congressional elections, and historical state voting patterns as anything else – though it’s hard to convey the significance of North Carolina as a battleground state without reinforcing those earlier stereotypes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)